Jump to content
Brett Manyluk

Alternative Brands, thoughts?

Recommended Posts

So... the time is coming for me once again to replace a round of batteries. I've always used Anton Bauers and have enjoyed their performance. Buuuutttttt... It's worth opening a dialogue up to see what else is on the market, who's using it and what they think. In a world of big capacity needs and falling budgets, it's worth having a look around at the other options. I fully recognize that IDX and Pag build great battery systems as well and are comparable in price/performance (if not superior in some cases), but I'm mostly interested in hearing about the other brands. You know, the Swits, and Varizooms, and Switronix, and generic rebrand #42 etc, etc, etc. Who's using them, how have they been, how are the chargers, charging time, flakiness factor, capacity, price, performance, lifespan, did it burn your house down, are you on a no-fly list for too many made in china products in your possession, etc, etc, etc...

 

Thoughts?

 

Again, this thread already recognizes that Pag, Anton Bauer, and IDX/Tiffen are the cream of crop. Moving on to the wallmart section of B&H...

 

Thanks!

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Brett,

I switched over to the China Made Lithium batteries from Video Tech supply, http://www.videotechsupply.com/

I fly the A/B Mount 190s and I some times double it up with a 190 and a 90, still less weight than an A/B 140 and half the price with double the run time.

 

Bad news is you have to use their charger, the dual travel charger is pretty cool but the quad charger is kinda cheaply made.

 

Overall very happy

 

PS: if you end up ordering from them ask for Mike Kirchner and tell him I recommended you, it never hurts to do a little PR once in awhile, he was very cool and on top of it, when I needed something.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used the chinese crap for a few years and the are ok. Only when you use a power hungry camera then you are gonne see the difference with the ab batterys and the chinese stuff. The dont hold it as long as a ab battery das. Also, the seems to get worser after a few high amp sessions. So, it might be cheaper at the beginning, but i hope the ab will be cheaper on the long run. I changed over to the AB HC's and it feels more solid in preformance.

 

J

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used the chinese crap for a few years and the are ok. Only when you use a power hungry camera then you are gonne see the difference with the ab batterys and the chinese stuff. The dont hold it as long as a ab battery das. Also, the seems to get worser after a few high amp sessions. So, it might be cheaper at the beginning, but i hope the ab will be cheaper on the long run. I changed over to the AB HC's and it feels more solid in preformance.

 

J

I owned four AB Dionic 90 HC batteries, but after changing to the VLock system we have used china batteries. Some were crap, but the ones we use now are great.

We use 190's and 160's from Global Media Pro.

They have never failed me, and they have been beaten and used alot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So... the time is coming for me once again to replace a round of batteries. I've always used Anton Bauers and have enjoyed their performance. Buuuutttttt... It's worth opening a dialogue up to see what else is on the market, who's using it and what they think. In a world of big capacity needs and falling budgets, it's worth having a look around at the other options. I fully recognize that IDX and Pag build great battery systems as well and are comparable in price/performance (if not superior in some cases), but I'm mostly interested in hearing about the other brands. You know, the Swits, and Varizooms, and Switronix, and generic rebrand #42 etc, etc, etc. Who's using them, how have they been, how are the chargers, charging time, flakiness factor, capacity, price, performance, lifespan, did it burn your house down, are you on a no-fly list for too many made in china products in your possession, etc, etc, etc...

 

Thoughts?

 

Again, this thread already recognizes that Pag, Anton Bauer, and IDX/Tiffen are the cream of crop. Moving on to the wallmart section of B&H...

 

Thanks!

 

I quit buying new batts and began getting them recelled. I am deep into AB batts/chargers so I'm very happy with recells by third party at half price of new. They come back stronger and lighter.

 

John A

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So... the time is coming for me once again to replace a round of batteries. I've always used Anton Bauers and have enjoyed their performance. Buuuutttttt... It's worth opening a dialogue up to see what else is on the market, who's using it and what they think. In a world of big capacity needs and falling budgets, it's worth having a look around at the other options. I fully recognize that IDX and Pag build great battery systems as well and are comparable in price/performance (if not superior in some cases), but I'm mostly interested in hearing about the other brands. You know, the Swits, and Varizooms, and Switronix, and generic rebrand #42 etc, etc, etc. Who's using them, how have they been, how are the chargers, charging time, flakiness factor, capacity, price, performance, lifespan, did it burn your house down, are you on a no-fly list for too many made in china products in your possession, etc, etc, etc...

 

Thoughts?

 

Again, this thread already recognizes that Pag, Anton Bauer, and IDX/Tiffen are the cream of crop. Moving on to the wallmart section of B&H...

 

Thanks!

 

I quit buying new batts and began getting them recelled. I am deep into AB batts/chargers so I'm very happy with recells by third party at half price of new. They come back stronger and lighter.

 

John A

 

 

What third party does the recelling on the ABs?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Tom,

 

There is a fellow who posts up in the "Steadicam-Marketplace" forum here. He has an eBay storefront as well. A quick peruse through "Marketplace" and you will find it. He posted, I believe, about a month ago.

 

I have spent some time poking around locally and have found one that will do it. There are several that come up in Google as well. If they recell NiCads, they should be able to recell them. Things like TrimPacs and Hytrons are candidates for recelling.

 

There appear to be quite a few veteran ops that recell their Hytrons and such. Hopefully they will chime in with some of their experiences particularly with the problems some of the recellers may have with some of A/B proprietary "Logic Series" stuff they have in the batts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Tom,

 

There is a fellow who posts up in the "Steadicam-Marketplace" forum here. He has an eBay storefront as well. A quick peruse through "Marketplace" and you will find it. He posted, I believe, about a month ago.

 

I have spent some time poking around locally and have found one that will do it. There are several that come up in Google as well. If they recell NiCads, they should be able to recell them. Things like TrimPacs and Hytrons are candidates for recelling.

 

There appear to be quite a few veteran ops that recell their Hytrons and such. Hopefully they will chime in with some of their experiences particularly with the problems some of the recellers may have with some of A/B proprietary "Logic Series" stuff they have in the batts.

 

Thanks Andrew. Do you know if Dionic 90s can be recelled?

Edited by Tom Daigon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Do you know if Dionic 90s can be recelled?

 

I can't definitively answer that. Seen a lot of conflicting info on that question. However, things do point towards "no".

 

 

EDIT:

 

The fellow who does recelling, the one who posted up recently, his name is John Ritter.

Edited by Andrew Stone

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Found a place that has the required "bench gear" to recell Dionics. You can find it here.

Thanks Andrew. I did some extensive research at Resellerratings.com and it appears that this company has a lot of people who are dissatisfied with their service. It seems that buying a new battery in the long run is a safer bet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Upon further investigation, John Ritter (not the dead actor) seems to have a wonderful track record recelling AB batteries. You can see his customers reviews with a Google search for user- ritter9

Edited by Tom Daigon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Say, anybody out there using Swits or Varizoom batteries (same batteries, different label)? Any thoughts on life, support, flakiness, chargers, etc? And which models are you using?

 

Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×