Jump to content

Broadcast or Microwave? A conundrum.


Recommended Posts

  • Premium Members

I'm faced with getting an illegal broadcast transmitter or microwave unit and I honestly can't decide.

 

Broadcast units seem to be very popular even on the big shows. There seem to be a number of suppliers. Being able to view the signal with little portable TV tuners and regular TV's is very convenient. I'm currently using the Hermes receiver and it works great. Personally, I don't care about illegal transmission, but I do if I get busted. From what I've heard, some studios are starting to crack down on this and if you get caught, your whole rig can be confiscated (this is what I've heard).

 

From what I hear, microwave units work great, but they're not as flexible as the broadcast transmitters and getting multiple receivers can really add up. But you'll never have to worry about doing something illegal.

 

Rumor has it the Modulus 4000 is going to be microwave?

 

If you didn't already have a wireless video setup, what would you do? I'm really on the fence. Thanks.

 

Dan "Channel Surfer" Coplan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members

Hey Dan,

 

I have both a modulus 3000 and a canatrans. My modulus is acting up so I bought the canatrans because I knew customer service with them (canatrans / lentiquip) would be key. Modulus go down and you have to wait forever to get it back. The Canatrans works like a champ. I am very impressed with it. My modulus is good to but I need to get it serviced. I also own a hermes reciever. The cool thing about the canatrans is that you can reduce the signal power. Check it out. Emery at lentiquip rocks.

 

BJ McDonnell

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Moderators

And for those not aware, the Canatrans now operates from channels 20-50! Yes, much needed additional channels and a better user interface. For those who've already made the plunge, units can be upgraded (Emery turned mine around in a day or so) for a $100 (covers parts).

 

Once again, Emery raises the bar.

 

I think you HAVE to have a UHF transmitter in this biz because everyone on set is using watchmen these days (sound mixers, ADs, etc). I've even seen boom ops with a tiny watchman strapped to their wrist.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members
My modulus is good to but I need to get it serviced. I also own a hermes reciever.

 

BJ McDonnell

BJ,

I recently had some problems with my modulus and I sent it to Dave Hable at Cramped Attic. I won't receive it back from him until tommorrow, so I've yet to use it since the repair, but his customer service has been really good. He did the repairs and an upgrade quickly, and didn't charge an arm and a leg.

I just thought you might like another option when looking for a place to get your unit repaired.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members

I've decided to go with the Titan microwave system from Transvideo. Not only is it legal (still not sure how much of an issue this is), but the breakup seems to come in the form of white horizontal lines across an otherwise stable image as opposed to the waving and noise degradation experienced with broadcast systems.

 

I was concerned about not being able to use the handy little TV tuners, but the receiver has a video out that I can use to go to my single channel "illegal" transmitter as well if the studio has to have them - best of both worlds.

 

Dan Coplan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members
...... but the breakup seems to come in the form of white horizontal lines across an otherwise stable image as opposed to the waving and noise degradation experienced with broadcast systems.

 

Dan Coplan

 

 

The white horizontal lines are most likely from an follow focus device such as the Preston or Scorpia, which spreads it's transmission on the same channels,

 

You can often find a channel combination between the 2 that works best.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members

Actually, this particular breakup was most likely from walkabout phones on the same frequency. The Titan is not supposed to suffer interference from follow focus - at least it better not!

 

Word on the street has it that walkabout phones are moving from 2.4GHz to 5.SomethingGHz which is good.

 

Dan Coplan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

I am currently working on a video transmitter solution for the film and video industry. I've collaborated with my uncle up in Spokane Washington, he has years of experience making video transmitters for surveillance. I submitted a design request that incorporates the same Hirosche connector as the Modulus with video and power(we don't want to be in the cable business), takes 9-36Volts DC, has BNC input and has been tested to run at least three weeks continuously with a range of 3/4 of a mile line of sight with a whip on the transmitter and yagi on the receiver. The prototype arriving in L.A. this week is a 700 Milliwatt 1.2 Ghz system with 4 seperate channels, easily changed with a slide switch. The production version will be available in two 1-watt versions - a 1.2 Ghz and 2.4 Ghz system, each with 8 channels. My uncle's contact at the FCC assured him that if it is not run 24 hours a day, it's legal.

 

We intend to make this very user friendly, and extremely durable. My uncle has many years of experience building equipment for the military and police, so everything is mil spec. I am currently looking for volunteers to field test this prototype and give me feedback regarding its stability and picture quality. The receiver uses a 4 Pin XLR power input for easy connection to block batteries, it too will take 9-36 volts and has a BNC output. Included is a whip antenna for the receiver, and a whip and yagi w/cable for the receiver. From what I understand, the yagi will rarely be necessary.

 

The reason for using 1.2 Ghz is that it is much less crowded than UHF. At the moment there is no sound cabability, but my uncle tells me it makes for a cleaner picture when you don't mix sound. I've been a boom operator for 13 years, and I've never seen a Modulus being used to transmit audio.

 

Please email me at kenstrain@dslextreme.com if you're interested in checking this out in Los Angeles, and I will schedule some time for you and bring it to your set. Your feed back is important, we're very hands on and would like to make service (when necessary), a top priority. We don't have a price yet, but it will probably be between the Modulus and the Canatrans. Thanks!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members
Actually, this particular breakup was most likely from walkabout phones on the same frequency. The Titan is not supposed to suffer interference from follow focus - at least it better not!

 

Word on the street has it that walkabout phones are moving from 2.4GHz to 5.SomethingGHz which is good.

 

Dan Coplan

 

 

Dan, you better believe it, I tried this, not only with the Titan system but also with the new and very nice PEDenz transmitter/receiver system. The last one has a diversity tuner, so it is more stable, but for sure, the white lines are there on many channels, particularly when the focus puller is in between the 2 video antennas (line of sight)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members

I have pondered this wireless issue for ages. Been using all the film 2.4ghz stuff out there as well as the high power illegal ones and got myself a modulus with transvideo recievers.... UHF is LOADS BETTER! ! absolutely without a doubt.

 

When u get breakup it comes in the way of gradual image degradation rather than synch loss and flickering image. It goes through and around walls. For my applications (100 yards maximum) the picture just is loads better! I am very very happy having gone UHF . The video playback boys are very impressed, they don t see much UHF here since it is illegal.

 

Thomas

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members

I have try the transvideo titan 4 channels in two setups

One time on the top of the camera , it work great with a excellent quality picture on 3 channels , I have noticed problems with the bartech transmitter on one channel .

The setup may not be easy to use with a camera raincover on the place I have put the titan .

Link :

http://www.pbase.com/kindofmagik/image/57517574

 

I have also try the 2 rainbow II superbright with integrated titan . I must say that it was wonderful for the operator and director , no more cables all is in the lcd monitor , also excellent quality picture the same as the titan and for the director , he just have a rainbow II lcd with back battery mount and antenna in the hands no cables . 4 hours of work with one pag 7.5A.

I have use this setup in new york,irlande,Australia and france without any problems .

Link :

http://www.pbase.com/kindofmagik/image/57517589

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...