Jump to content

PRO vs MK-V


Niko lasarte

Recommended Posts

  • Premium Members

Hi guys!

The first thing is to introduce myself. I'm Niko Lasarte, an operator established in spain.

The second thing to apologize for the mistakes in my English. any way, let´s see. :blink:

This is the time to change my old EFP sled by one most complete. I was in CINEC and I had the opportunity to test several rigs. :lol: :lol:

Among others tried the PRO and felt very comfortable. until now had the guru of the steadis (also because I was able to work with her and know her). also tried the MK-V and also felt very well, a very fine machine.

In favor of MK-V I see 2 things:

- Is a 4 stage sled (which can make a superpost in 5 minutes).

- It is ready to carry HD signal to the inside of the sled.

On the contrary: - price :o , and don´t know the weight sled. I have heard that working with light cameras can be uncomfortable. Has anyone had this experience?

PRO sled? I like a lot but I have a feeling that is lagging behind in some respects. With this future is coming ... (RED, ARRI D-21 and those coming!

I have also heard of XCS but I don´t know.

I would like to know your opinion on the matter. What do you think of the HD and post in 4 stage? So I can make myself a more complete idea and decide with more discretion.

Thank you very much ;)

 

Niko

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 36
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Premium Members

Hi Niko,

 

Costumer service and reliability are very important things. PRO has a great track record for both. Since you are located in Europe you should take a look at the RIG from Betz Tools. It's local (Munich) so you don't have to deal with the shipping to the USA. It has a 4-stage post and is HD-SDI capable! Very solid Rig. They are also a dealer/service for PRO in Europe.

 

Betz-Tools RIG

 

Jens

 

 

 

Hi guys!

The first thing is to introduce myself. I'm Niko Lasarte, an operator established in spain.

The second thing to apologize for the mistakes in my English. any way, let´s see. :blink:

This is the time to change my old EFP sled by one most complete. I was in CINEC and I had the opportunity to test several rigs. :lol: :lol:

Among others tried the PRO and felt very comfortable. until now had the guru of the steadis (also because I was able to work with her and know her). also tried the MK-V and also felt very well, a very fine machine.

In favor of MK-V I see 2 things:

- Is a 4 stage sled (which can make a superpost in 5 minutes).

- It is ready to carry HD signal to the inside of the sled.

On the contrary: - price :o , and don´t know the weight sled. I have heard that working with light cameras can be uncomfortable. Has anyone had this experience?

PRO sled? I like a lot but I have a feeling that is lagging behind in some respects. With this future is coming ... (RED, ARRI D-21 and those coming!

I have also heard of XCS but I don´t know.

I would like to know your opinion on the matter. What do you think of the HD and post in 4 stage? So I can make myself a more complete idea and decide with more discretion.

Thank you very much ;)

 

Niko

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members

Niko:

 

We have a saying here that compares opinions to a certain part of the anatomy, with the tag being "everyone's got one".

 

Jen's point about buying local is well-taken; for us in LA, it's a fantastic boon to be able to drive over to either GPI (PRO) or to Greg Bubb (XCS) for your servicing. A European manufacturer may have similar advantages for you.

 

HD capability does indeed narrow the possibilities a bit. If you want a rig with HD-SDI and monitoring in a turnkey package, only a few of the manufacturers offer that (including one not on your list, Tiffen--the Ultra 2 is a nice rig!)

 

Without rehashing some of the more controversial debates that have gone on in the Forum in recent years, definitely do some searching here regarding the manufacturers you have listed and you will find some interesting opinions!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members

hey niko

another rig that doesn't get mentioned here is the sachtler "artemis" rig

it comes hd,sdi,sd and component ready and they are in munich as well

 

 

 

 

 

Hi guys!

The first thing is to introduce myself. I'm Niko Lasarte, an operator established in spain.

The second thing to apologize for the mistakes in my English. any way, let´s see. :blink:

This is the time to change my old EFP sled by one most complete. I was in CINEC and I had the opportunity to test several rigs. :lol: :lol:

Among others tried the PRO and felt very comfortable. until now had the guru of the steadis (also because I was able to work with her and know her). also tried the MK-V and also felt very well, a very fine machine.

In favor of MK-V I see 2 things:

- Is a 4 stage sled (which can make a superpost in 5 minutes).

- It is ready to carry HD signal to the inside of the sled.

On the contrary: - price :o , and don´t know the weight sled. I have heard that working with light cameras can be uncomfortable. Has anyone had this experience?

PRO sled? I like a lot but I have a feeling that is lagging behind in some respects. With this future is coming ... (RED, ARRI D-21 and those coming!

I have also heard of XCS but I don´t know.

I would like to know your opinion on the matter. What do you think of the HD and post in 4 stage? So I can make myself a more complete idea and decide with more discretion.

Thank you very much ;)

 

Niko

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members

Artemis HD

 

Yes, sachtler has a nice rig, but they are a big, big, company, - Christian Betz on the other and builds and lives Steadicam for 20 years...

 

 

hey niko

another rig that doesn't get mentioned here is the sachtler "artemis" rig

it comes hd,sdi,sd and component ready and they are in munich as well

 

 

 

 

 

Hi guys!

The first thing is to introduce myself. I'm Niko Lasarte, an operator established in spain.

The second thing to apologize for the mistakes in my English. any way, let´s see. :blink:

This is the time to change my old EFP sled by one most complete. I was in CINEC and I had the opportunity to test several rigs. :lol: :lol:

Among others tried the PRO and felt very comfortable. until now had the guru of the steadis (also because I was able to work with her and know her). also tried the MK-V and also felt very well, a very fine machine.

In favor of MK-V I see 2 things:

- Is a 4 stage sled (which can make a superpost in 5 minutes).

- It is ready to carry HD signal to the inside of the sled.

On the contrary: - price :o , and don´t know the weight sled. I have heard that working with light cameras can be uncomfortable. Has anyone had this experience?

PRO sled? I like a lot but I have a feeling that is lagging behind in some respects. With this future is coming ... (RED, ARRI D-21 and those coming!

I have also heard of XCS but I don´t know.

I would like to know your opinion on the matter. What do you think of the HD and post in 4 stage? So I can make myself a more complete idea and decide with more discretion.

Thank you very much ;)

 

Niko

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members
Hi guys!

The first thing is to introduce myself. I'm Niko Lasarte, an operator established in spain.

The second thing to apologize for the mistakes in my English. any way, let´s see. :blink:

This is the time to change my old EFP sled by one most complete. I was in CINEC and I had the opportunity to test several rigs. :lol: :lol:

Among others tried the PRO and felt very comfortable. until now had the guru of the steadis (also because I was able to work with her and know her). also tried the MK-V and also felt very well, a very fine machine.

In favor of MK-V I see 2 things:

- Is a 4 stage sled (which can make a superpost in 5 minutes).

- It is ready to carry HD signal to the inside of the sled.

On the contrary: - price :o , and don´t know the weight sled. I have heard that working with light cameras can be uncomfortable. Has anyone had this experience?

PRO sled? I like a lot but I have a feeling that is lagging behind in some respects. With this future is coming ... (RED, ARRI D-21 and those coming!

I have also heard of XCS but I don´t know.

I would like to know your opinion on the matter. What do you think of the HD and post in 4 stage? So I can make myself a more complete idea and decide with more discretion.

Thank you very much ;)

 

Niko

 

XCS can do HD no problem, there is a SDI line already in the post. Sales and service are top notch

 

Pro Solid rig and a solid company like XCS sales and service are top notch

 

Tiffen Great products and service

 

Sachtler, No real innovations a copy-cat company

 

MK-V.... Well I suggest you talk to some others and also check them on their deliver times. (Talk to Job Scholtze and Juan Ramos) I had their pro conversion, the rewire the post for no apparent reason and use small gauge wire, the 4 stage post is nice but I never had the need to run it in superpost mode so it was just un-needed weight

 

Bottom line is that you need to look at who is going to give you the best service after the sale. It's easy to be your best friend and promise you the world in order to get the sale, it's how they handle themselves AFTER the money changes hands.

 

I believe in shopping locally (XCS, Pro, Preston) and that decision has never haunted me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Site Sponsor

Dear Niko,

didn't you visit us at cinec on our booth Betz-Tools ?

The Rig has anything you are searching for also one of the best known service station in europe.

ask:

Carlos Cabeceran

Steadimakers in France (sam alga)

etc.

If you ave any questions or need a demo RIG don't hesitate to contact us you are wellcome

 

info@betz-tools.com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members

Dear Niko,

 

Being an owner of PRO, XCS & MK-V components, I feel qualified to comment on your questions. Eric's points are all well taken. THE MOST important thing to look for in a company is how they will support you after the sale. I agree it's tougher to support someone overseas, but I'd rather have an overseas company with great support than one next door with poor support. You cannot go wrong with the component quality and unsurpassed support given by PRO & XCS.

 

I looked at the 4 stage post, and I didn't like 3 things about it. 1) carrying the extra weight, 2) too long a post for my taste 3) minimal need for a superpost & not worth carrying it all the time. As far as HD, consider what else on your rig needs to be HD, like video transmitter, on board recorder, etc... Until everything can be HD, I'm sticking with a downconverted signal. It is worth buying a rig that has the proper guage cable to be able to carry HD signals in the future.

 

The good thing about buying a Steadicam today is all the choices. The bad thing about buying a Steadicam today is all the choices!!

 

Take care,

mark

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members

Hello Gentlemen.

Hi Mark. Couldn't agree with you more about the downconverter sitch.

Untill the market produces not only an affordable xmitter but affordable hand held Casio-like easy LCD's, I'll continue use a down converter. Having small handhelds for the director or whomever is huge. I'll do anything to keep people from hovering over my shoulder.

On manufacturers, Local service is huge! But Great Service is even more important. I own MK-V, PRO, Preston, Transvideo, Canatrans and Klassen gear.

Out of all of those MK-V has been tough to deal with. Sending gear across the pond is expensive, time consuming and has the potential to cost you work because of displaced gear. Until MK-V can establish a proper support facility here in the US they will be at a distinct disadvantage. Hope Howard gets that worked out very soon.

Can't say enough about the others I mentioned.

Also, can't wait for Howard Preston to come out with the larger Cinetape display screen for the HU3!

 

Ramon

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members
Also, can't wait for Howard Preston to come out with the larger Cinetape display screen for the HU3!

 

Ramon

 

You already bought the $700 cable to make the ac's life easier...maybe it should be up to the ac to buy the bigger display?

Not to mention the $7400 for the HU3!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members

I am a big fan of GPI PRO! they have always had killer customer service. Never a problem and they are quick to repair or clean. XCS all I have is 2 TB-6 monitors and Greg Bubb has always been killer when I need to have them serviced or cleaned. I can't say much for MK-V other than I liked the PRO gimbal upgrade they sold me before I got a VZ gimbal. I say PRO is the way to go if you live in the US for sure. MK-V if you are in Europe. Just my 2 cents. OH yea and Lisigav is a must for all sleds.

 

 

BJ McDonnell

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Premium Members
Hey Niko,

 

One thing I forgot to mention is that, being in Europe & buying with Euro's, you'd get a great deal on PRO or XCS due to the falling US dollar. Check the current exchange, but I bet you'd save nearly 30%.

 

Worth a look,

Mark

 

 

You need to take a look at the currency markets, the Dollar is rallying against the euro, right now it's only 22% weaker

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...